On September 11th, two hip-hop superstars, 50 Cent and Kanye West are both releasing their new albums. 50 Cent, miffed that Kanye actually moved up the release date for Graduation to match his release date for Curtis, was so confident that his album would outsell Kanye’s that he vowed to retire if Kanye beat him. He has since recanted, but it’s clear that the war for hip-hop supremacy is on.
So which is better? I am not a hip-hop/rap fan in general. I don’t seek it out, and it’s not usually a part of my daily listening. As such, I have no alliances to either rapper and think I may have a better chance to objectively evaluate the two cds and determine a victor. (That also could be a load of crap- who knows). Either way, as the albums drop at midnight I will listen and evaluate each in the hopes of determining a victor. Stick around and find out what I think.
Update: 12:01 PM 9/11/07.
Sorry for the delay, I simply fell asleep and didn’t get to finish the albums or do the reviews last night; however, I have completed both, made my notes, and am prepared to deliver my uselessreview.
Kanye West – Graduation
Starting with Kanye… The Graduation stars with a gradual build up- “Good Morning” is a mid tempo track that allows you to slowly “wake up” into the album. “Champion” feels like it borrowed its beat from “Mo’ Money, Mo Problems” which is not a complaint. It’s a great dance beat and highly addictive. It seems like Kanye wants to believe that he can act as an inspiration to kids because of his success. “Stronger” was probably the best track on the cd- I loved the new wave 80’s electronic voice that plays in the background with the sparse synth. I’m dating myself, but listening to it, I could see kids roller skating to the song at the local rink. “Wonder” is West’s first misstep. The rhyming is to syncopated and doesn’t feel like it flows together very well. Good Life has a party vibe and Can’t Tell Me Nothing bring the feel back and bring you back into the album.
Unfortunately the album hits a major pair of speed bumps when we get to Barry Bonds and Drunk and Hot Girls. Neither seem to go anywhere to me and just killed the flow of the album (Mos Def’s appearance on Drunk and Hot Girls was the only high spot on an otherwise insipid track).
After getting past the psuedo love song that is Flashing Light, West really gets back on track with “Everything I Am” a slow jam where West tells us how he doesn’t measure up to some other artists in some ways, but as a result is able to be the artist he is. The Glory brings back the dance beats (With a Jackson 5 sounding intro). He brings in Chris Martin (doing his best Sting impersonation) to help him with his shout-out to Detroit, Homecoming.
The final track, Big Brother, is a curious track. West raps about Jay-Z’s influence on his career, but also seems to take swipes at Jay as well. West complains about being told he could buy a ticket to a Jay-Z MSG show and decries Jay doing a track with Coldplay after finding out that West himself was doing a track with Coldplay. West also acknowledges his own missteps, having not discussed issues with Jay directly. I guess it is ultimately a tribute because he tells Jay he loves him and bemoans the fact that “people never get flowers while they can still smell ‘em”.
50 Cent – Curtis
Unlike Graduation’s gentle “Good Morning,” 50 comes blazing out of the gates with “My Gun.” 50 makes it very clear that nobody stands in his way and he’ll establish his position at anyone’s expense. There was a “Lose Youself” quote in the track that I found to be a bit strange for someone as established as 50, but it works.
There’s a definite theme to Curtis- hustling, murder, and sex. In man down, 50’s accused of murdering someone he doesn’t know, but everyone knows he has his posse do his murders for him. I’ll Still Kill follows the same theme. In I Got Money, 50 brags about being so rich that “have a baby by me baby, become a millionaire, I’ll write the check before the baby comes, who the f— cares.” And so the album goes with guest appearances by Justin Timberlake, Robin Thicke, Mary J Blige and Eminem among others. 50 Cent’s ability to carry a microphone is unquestionable and the album flows from track to track nicely with no miscues.
Comparing the two albums:
50 Cent’s execution is flawless. He’s confident and his ability to control a mic is unparalleled- ignoring anything he’s actually saying, his delivery is amazing. Peepshow in particular illustrates his uncanny ability to integrate really cool vocal rhythms into his raps.
West, on the other hand, isn’t consistent throughout the entire album. His delivery is good, but there are a few times where it seems like he’s forcing the lyrics to meet the rhythm and it falls a bit flat.
Thematically, perhaps 50 is a bit too limited, and that’s where Kanye takes an edge. One 50 Cent track is like just about any other in terms of what you’re going to hear- posturing, money, sex. Kanye is a bit more introspective and with Big Brother, Champion, and Everything I Am manages to go in three different direction, with three different styles and make it all work (though there is definately a clothing theme throughout the album- Mr. West likes his designer clothes).
50 Cent wants to intimidate and scare you, Kanye wants to pat himself on the back but still inspire you. 50 Cent probably takes the nod for delivering the better, more cohesive album with Curtis (he’s definately the better rapper based on these two discs), but Graduation seems to have the more radio and club friendly tracks and will probably get a lot more play. I have a feeling that although 50’s disc is better overall, Kanye will probably win the battle on the charts.
Much to my surprise, I enjoyed both albums quite a bit (I’ll admit that I really didn’t expect to be enthralled with either), so you can plan on seeing more outsider reviews like this in the future.